Key Takeaways:
- Kazuhiko Torishima believes One Piece has creatively declined over the years due to a lack of editorial control.
- He once opposed its serialization, citing technical flaws in storytelling and presentation.
- His comments have sparked new debates about creative freedom versus editorial influence in long-running manga.
As One Piece continues to enjoy global dominance across anime, manga, and live-action media, former Shonen Jump editor Kazuhiko Torishima has stirred controversy with candid comments about the long-running series. During an interview with France Info at Japan Expo Paris 2025, Torishima stated that One Piece “deteriorated” over time and that its creator, Eiichiro Oda, may now be beyond editorial guidance.
Torishima Once Opposed One Piece’s Serialization
Kazuhiko Torishima, best known for editing Dragon Ball and later becoming Shonen Jump’s editor-in-chief, has a complicated history with One Piece. When Oda’s pirate adventure was first pitched in 1997, Torishima opposed its serialization, calling it “boring” and technically flawed. Although he eventually approved it, his initial hesitation stemmed from concerns about its accessibility to young readers.
His comments this week reignite that skepticism. “At the time, I thought it had improved, but then it deteriorated,” he said. “I think his editors can no longer tell him anything. The author won over the editors.”
Also read: Amazon Prime Day 2025: Best Xbox Deals on Consoles, Game Pass, SSDs & Accessories
Oda’s Creative Autonomy Under Scrutiny
Torishima’s view suggests that Eiichiro Oda’s legendary status may now limit editorial oversight. While Oda is praised for One Piece’s intricate storytelling and massive worldbuilding, critics argue the series has become bloated and difficult to follow.
Fans are split. Some appreciate Torishima’s honesty and industry insight, while others see it as an outdated perspective on modern manga. One reader commented, “It resonates with me. The recent arcs feel too drawn out.”
Editorial Influence in Manga: A Vanishing Art?
Torishima’s remarks also sparked discussion about the diminishing role of editors in long-running manga. “The editor is the first reader,” he said. “They should make sure the story works before it goes out.” He emphasized that editors must provide constructive criticism—even when it’s hard to hear.
This approach contrasts with today’s manga climate, where top-tier creators often have more say than their editors, especially after achieving global success.
One Piece Debate Rekindled
Kazuhiko Torishima’s critique has reignited conversations around One Piece’s current direction and the shifting power dynamics between manga creators and editors. Whether readers agree with his assessment or not, his comments highlight the importance of editorial guidance in maintaining narrative quality—even in legendary works.
Disclaimer: The information in this article is for general purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. The author’s views are personal and may not reflect the views of GameDegen.com. Before making any investment decisions, you should always conduct your own research. GameDegen.com is not responsible for any financial losses.