EA’s “Biggest Franchise Update” Claim Meets Real-World Skepticism
Electronic Arts is hyping Madden NFL 26 as delivering the “biggest Franchise update in over a decade,” a headline that’s likely to be repeated by content creators and fans alike. But longtime Madden players—especially those who’ve seen past updates fall flat—aren’t buying into the excitement just yet. The Franchise mode, once a cornerstone of the series, has suffered years of inconsistent improvements and broken features. And for many fans, especially those in tightly-knit online leagues, it’s clear that the mode’s success relies more on community than on EA’s design.
Storylines That Break More Than They Build
In Madden 25, EA introduced weekly narrative challenges meant to infuse the Franchise experience with realism. But those storylines frequently malfunctioned or failed to make logical sense. Challenges often penalized players for exceeding expectations, such as a sack total not matching an exact number—even when surpassing it. Other rewards, like XP boosts for benching a rookie QB, routinely underdelivered. From robotic player meetings to nonsensical sideline conversations, the effort to add human drama fell short, often coming off more like parody than progress.
Also read: 7 Underrated Batman Family Comics Every Fan Should Read
Madden 26’s New Features Sound Promising—But Execution Is Key
The Madden 26 Franchise update introduces deeper scouting, signature player traits, revamped play suggestions using generative AI, and more realistic animations. On paper, it all sounds compelling. But past implementations of similar ideas—like Patrick Mahomes’ sidearm pass or Saquon Barkley’s backward hurdle—quickly became gimmicks rather than transformative gameplay features. Players are especially skeptical about the generative AI suggestions, given that even basic play-calling logic has been broken in recent years.
Good Ideas, Poorly Executed—A Madden Franchise Pattern
Madden’s Franchise direction over the past several years reveals a clear trend: solid ideas that lack proper execution. Fans want immersive storytelling, realistic coaching dynamics, and player personalities that mirror their real-life counterparts. What they’ve gotten instead are unfinished features, tone-deaf writing, and UI errors that persist across yearly iterations. Many devoted Franchise players now ignore the storyline system altogether, finding that the game plays better when those broken mechanics are skipped entirely.
Ultimately, Madden 26 may still be the best version yet on the field—but off the field, Franchise mode remains under scrutiny. EA’s promises sound familiar, and for many fans, that’s exactly the problem.
Disclaimer: The information in this article is for general purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. The author’s views are personal and may not reflect the views of GameDegen.com. Before making any investment decisions, you should always conduct your own research. GameDegen.com is not responsible for any financial losses.
