Key Takeaways:
- Elden Ring Nightreign’s gameplay loop and alternate universe format fit naturally into Bloodborne‘s lore.
- The Great Ones provide a lore-consistent way to expand the world without breaking canon.
- Bloodborne’s endings already set up a cyclical, dream-like framework perfect for a spin-off narrative.
Bloodborne is widely hailed as one of the greatest games of the PlayStation 4 era, but it has yet to receive a sequel or a proper remake. While FromSoftware’s Hidetaka Miyazaki has famously avoided direct sequels, the recent release of Elden Ring Nightreign may offer a new opportunity. Its core structure and lore create a near-perfect mold for a potential Bloodborne Nightreign spin-off that stays true to the original while innovating in new directions.
Nightreign’s Gameplay Loop Could Elevate Bloodborne’s Formula
At its core, Elden Ring Nightreign embraces roguelike and cooperative elements within a time-limited loop—challenging players to defeat multiple Nightlords before the world resets. This fresh take on FromSoftware’s Soulslike foundation introduces new design philosophy while maintaining high-stakes progression. A similar formula applied to Bloodborne could expand its horror and madness themes with added replayability and lore experimentation.
Instead of Nightlords, Bloodborne Nightreign could pit players against a selection of Great Ones across three nights, each encounter resetting the dreamscape. The spin-off could even include cooperative “Hunters” with unique motivations and stories, echoing Nightreign’s Nightfarers.
Also read: Stop Killing Games Petition Hits 1 Million Signatures, EU Lobby Responds with Opposition
Lore-Friendly: Bloodborne’s Great Ones Enable Multiplanar Spin-Offs
Unlike Elden Ring, which needed to justify Nightreign’s alternate universe with new narrative context, Bloodborne already supports multiverse storytelling. The existence of the Hunter’s Dream and the influence of the Moon Presence offer a built-in explanation for new planes of reality. A Great One birthing a new dream or realm—similar to Limveld in Nightreign—wouldn’t break canon but rather enrich it.
The potential for returning bosses like Ebrietas, Amygdala, or the Orphan of Kos—each reimagined in a new dream realm—makes the concept even more compelling. Meanwhile, reused assets and gothic environments could remain artistically consistent with Bloodborne‘s nightmarish tone.
Bloodborne’s Endings Already Set Up a Perfect Spin-Off Loop
The three endings of Bloodborne practically demand further exploration. Whether the Hunter becomes the new caretaker of the Dream, replaces Gehrman, or ascends to Great One status, each path supports the idea of a repeating, tragic cycle. A Nightreign-style story could follow the fallout of these choices, exploring the same endless loop of ascension, loss, and cosmic madness.
Even a subtle nod that one of the bosses might be a past player-Hunter turned Great One would ignite the lore community, creating the same speculative energy that has fueled FromSoftware fandoms for years.
Bloodborne Nightreign Makes Too Much Sense to Ignore
A Bloodborne Nightreign spin-off wouldn’t just satisfy long-time fans—it would allow FromSoftware to honor the original while exploring bold new gameplay ideas. With Elden Ring Nightreign setting the precedent, Sony and FromSoftware have a ready-made blueprint for Bloodborne’s rebirth.
Disclaimer: The information in this article is for general purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. The author’s views are personal and may not reflect the views of GameDegen.com. Before making any investment decisions, you should always conduct your own research. GameDegen.com is not responsible for any financial losses.
